Even when a vacation isn’t perfect, I can usually find the positives among the hiccups. After all, I’ve taken 55 cruises, so I understand that no vacation goes exactly as planned. Delayed flights, long lines, bad weather, and disappointing meals are all part of the travel experience from time to time.
However, my recent cruise on Carnival Sunshine was different. Unfortunately, it was one of the worst cruise experiences I’ve had. They can’t all be winners, right?!
Although my sister and I tried to make the most of our 4-night Bahamas cruise, we spent much of the sailing dealing with a noisy cabin, unpleasant smells, crowded public areas, and inconsistent food.

By the end of the cruise, I was counting down the days until disembarkation, which I’ve never done before.
Carnival Sunshine is technically Carnival Cruise Line’s oldest ship currently. But when she originally launched as Carnival Destiny in 1996, the ship was considered revolutionary. At the time, Carnival Destiny was the largest passenger cruise ship in the world and the first cruise ship to measure more than 100,000 gross tons.
In 2013, the ship underwent a massive $155 million refurbishment. Carnival essentially gutted the ship down to its hull during a 49-day dry dock, adding new restaurants, entertainment venues, cabins and redesigned public spaces. The transformation was so extensive that the ship received a new name: Carnival Sunshine.

Even though Carnival Sunshine received this impressive makeover, the ship’s bones are still nearly 30 years old. I’ve sailed on many older ships and don’t automatically dismiss a ship because of its age.
Even still, Carnival Sunshine showed its age in ways I wasn’t prepared for. Here’s my truly honest review for why Carnival Sunshine was one of the worst cruises I’ve ever taken.
It’s important to note that Carnival Sunshine went through a scheduled dry dock after my summer 2024 sailing. The work included technical maintenance, updates to public areas, and stateroom improvements. The ship also no longer sails from Charleston, where we boarded. My review reflects my personal experience before those updates.
Why we chose to cruise on Carnival Sunshine

My sister and I wanted to take a quick cruise together before the end of the summer – and Carnival Cruise Line is known for having cheap getaway sailings! Since we had never sailed from Charleston, we thought Carnival Sunshine would be a convenient option for a short Bahamas cruise.
The ship also had some personal significance. We had sailed on Carnival Destiny with our parents in 2011, before the ship received her massive refurbishment and became Carnival Sunshine. So, we were curious to see how the ship compared more than a decade later.
Because of this history, we were really interested to see how the ship had held up. Honestly, I’ve sailed on plenty of older cruise ships and don’t believe that a ship has to be new to offer a good vacation. Unfortunately, Carnival Sunshine’s age was more noticeable than I expected.
The cruise started with a difficult embarkation

We arrived at the terminal to board Carnival Sunshine around noon and didn’t board the ship until approximately 2:30 p.m. Most of that time was spent standing in long lines in the heat and humidity – not a great start to our cruise!
After being dropped off, we were directed to a nearby parking lot. From there, we walked outside to a tent where a line had already formed. Once inside, we found more lines weaving through the crowded space.
The fans were running, but they weren’t enough to keep the area comfortable. Everyone was sweating, and the longer we waited, the more miserable the process became.

At one point, every passenger had to place their luggage in a line while police dogs inspected the bags. This was actually the first time I had experienced drug-sniffing dogs during embarkation. I appreciated the extra security, but it added more time to an already lengthy process.
After the luggage inspection, we were sent into another tent inside the first tent. There was some air conditioning, but it did very little to cool down the crowded room.
Eventually, we boarded a shuttle to the ship and went through another security screening. By the time we stepped onboard, my sister and I were hot, tired, and hungry.
This was easily one of the worst embarkation experiences I’ve ever had. Thankfully, getting off the ship at the end of the cruise was much easier and more organized.
Our cabin was in a terrible location

To save money, we booked an interior guarantee stateroom (which was a huge mistake on this ship). With a guaranteed cabin, you aren’t able to select your specific cabin, so Carnival assigned our room closer to the sailing date.
We were given cabin 6314 on Deck 6. The room was classified as an ambulatory accessible cabin, even though we had not requested an accessible stateroom.
The cabin itself was fine, although it was not especially memorable. The decor was dated, but that was what I expected from an older ship and didn’t bother us. I can overlook older furniture and outdated designs as long as a cabin is clean and comfortable.
Unfortunately, the location made it extremely difficult to enjoy the room.

Our cabin shared a wall with an elevator shaft, so throughout the night, we heard loud thuds and clanking sounds every time the elevator moved. The wall next to my bed would literally shake, and the noise was deep enough to feel through the room.
I tried using earplugs and white noise, but nothing could drown it out. I considered asking to be moved to another cabin, although I wasn’t sure if any alternatives would be available on a full sailing.
The noise from the hallway was just as frustrating. Guests were running and yelling outside our door at all hours. The sound was so loud that it sometimes seemed as if people were literally standing inside our cabin.

I usually sleep well on cruises and often take an afternoon nap on sea days. On this sailing, I was exhausted because I could never fully relax or get enough sleep.
Booking a guarantee cabin was our choice, so I understand that we took a risk with the location. However, I was surprised that a stateroom was positioned directly beside an elevator shaft to begin with, as this seems like a terrible design.
The bathroom was the worst part of the cabin

The cabin bathroom created another set of problems. Almost immediately, we noticed a strong and unpleasant smell coming from the bathroom. We never figured out the source of the odor, and it continued throughout the entire cruise… unfortunately.
I’m used to encountering an occasional strange smell on a cruise ship, as it’s not unusual when you’re traveling on a large vessel. However, this smell was overpowering enough that we tried to avoid spending more time in the bathroom than necessary.
The shower was also frustrating to use. Every time we showered, water spread across the bathroom floor. The shower curtain did not contain the water very well, and the drain was unable to keep up.

On the first evening, we used several towels to clean up the standing water. Even after wiping the floor, it remained wet and cold until our cabin steward serviced the room. I am sure the standing water didn’t help with the rancid smell.
For me, the bathroom was the clearest example of how Carnival Sunshine’s age affected the cruise. I expected a dated cabin, but I didn’t expect a foul smell and a flooded floor every night.
The ship had unpleasant smells in other areas

Unfortunately, the bathroom wasn’t the only place where we noticed unpleasant odors, as there was a strong smell near the poolside entrance of the Lido Marketplace.
The odor actually became more noticeable as we walked through the buffet toward the pool deck. It was especially unfortunate because one of the self-serve ice cream machines was located nearby, which was a turn-off.
My sister and I love Carnival’s soft-serve ice cream, but we rarely felt like stopping there because of the smell. Our waistlines were thankful for this, at least!
We also noticed an odor near the Alchemy Bar and Ocean Plaza. We often sat in Ocean Plaza for trivia, so the smell became a recurring distraction during these activities.
Other passengers mentioned the odors in our sailing’s Facebook group, which confirmed that we weren’t imagining them. I don’t know exactly what caused the smells, but they made us question how well certain areas of the ship were being maintained.
Crowds made the older ship feel even smaller

Carnival Sunshine was sailing at full capacity with nearly 3,000 guests onboard. I’ve cruised on many sold-out ships, so I knew there would be crowds. However, Carnival Sunshine did not seem to handle the crowds as well as newer ships and we found the public areas felt cramped, especially during the two sea days.
The pool deck and Serenity area were both very crowded, and we had little interest in trying to find space around the pool. Lines also formed at many of the popular dining venues at all hours.
For instance, the pizza line at Cucina del Capitano was often out the door, while the panini station in the buffet was also extremely busy. The dining room had long lines in the evening unless guests arrived right when it opened.

Sadly, the Punchliner Comedy Club was another challenge for us. The venue was way too small for the number of people who wanted to attend, so guests often waited in line to get inside.
Oddly enough, the main theatre shows were never especially crowded and we were able to easily find seats. We enjoyed Epic Rock, one of the Playlist Productions shows, and thought it was one of the best entertainment offerings on the cruise.
Carnival Sunshine’s food was hit-or-miss

Carnival’s casual dining is one of the reasons I enjoy sailing with the cruise line. I usually find the food to be very reliable, even on older ships. That wasn’t entirely true on Carnival Sunshine.
We had several meals that were good, but the quality seemed to be inconsistent. After boarding, my sister and I ordered lunch from the pasta station, and while her order arrived, mine did not. I had to ask the staff to quickly prepare my meal before the restaurant closed, and it wasn’t exactly what I requested.

And while the main dining room had quick service, some of the food was disappointing. For example, normally we both like Carnival’s chicken cordon bleu, but this time it was dry. We found some of the entrees lacked flavor entirely, which really surprised us.
Unfortunately, SeaDay Brunch was another letdown. We had been looking forward to Carnival’s famous French toast, but it wasn’t the same as it had been on previous cruises.
Even the soft-serve ice cream tasted different than usual!
Fortunately, there were still some highlights. Guy’s Burger Joint was one of the best dining options onboard, and The Ringer burger was excellent. We also enjoyed several meals in the main dining room, and the chocolate melting cake was consistently delicious!
The food wasn’t terrible overall, it just didn’t live up to my usual Carnival experience.
There were still some fun things to do

Carnival Sunshine did have a full schedule of entertainment and activities onboard. We enjoyed SpongeBob SquarePants trivia, Taylor Swift trivia, and several other events throughout the cruise.
As mentioned, the Epic Rock production show was a highlight. The audience sang along, and some guests even stood up and danced during the performance.
We never ran out of activities during our cruise, and there were several things we didn’t have time to try. This was one area where Carnival Sunshine exceeded my expectations!
Even though the ship is older, it still offered plenty of entertainment. It would be difficult to get bored on Carnival Sunshine, especially for guests who enjoy trivia, live shows, and scheduled activities.
Would I sail on Carnival Sunshine again? Probably not.

Our Carnival Sunshine experience wasn’t completely negative. We enjoyed some of the food, liked several activities, and thought the entertainment was better than expected.
However, some of our bigger problems affected the entire cruise. The embarkation was exhausting, our cabin was almost impossible to sleep in, the bathroom was unpleasant, and the ship had noticeable odors throughout several public areas.
The high price also made the experience harder to justify. We paid approximately $1,700 for the cruise itself, and that was before adding flights, a hotel, and internet. For an older ship sailing a short Bahamas itinerary, the total cost felt excessive.

I also recognize that booking a guarantee cabin contributed to our experience. If we had selected a cabin away from the elevator, we may have slept better. But the bathroom issues, unpleasant smells, and crowds were unrelated to our cabin choice.
Carnival Sunshine has an interesting history, and I can understand why many cruisers still enjoy the ship. It offers a lively atmosphere, plenty of activities, and several of Carnival’s popular dining options.
However, based on my sailing, it was one of the worst cruise ships I’ve experienced.
The 2025 dry dock may have improved some of the ship’s public areas and outdoor spaces, so future passengers may have a different experience than we did. Even so, I would be hesitant to book Carnival Sunshine again unless the itinerary was exceptional or I found an incredible deal.

